Obama Judge Put Comey’s Daughter Back On the Payroll Using a Theory SCOTUS Already Killed

Oct 28, 2026

James Comey already stands criminally indicted for posting a coded threat against President Trump.

Now a federal judge just rewarded his daughter for getting fired from the same Justice Department.

The judge just put a Comey back on the taxpayer-funded payroll using a legal trick already pronounced dead.

An Obama Judge Picks a Fight With the Supreme Court

Maurene Comey walked out of the Southern District of New York earlier this year after Attorney General Pam Bondi's Justice Department fired her.

She was not fired for misconduct.

The DOJ admitted that in its own court filings.

She was fired because her last name is Comey, and because she spent a decade inside the very U.S. Attorney's office her father once ran before he became FBI director.

This was not Furman's first ruling against the DOJ in this case – he already let Maurene Comey's lawsuit move forward back in April, rejecting the government's bid to get it thrown out.

Judge Jesse Furman did not see it that way.

Furman is an Obama appointee sitting in Manhattan.

On Monday he ruled the firing illegal, ordered Maurene Comey reinstated, and awarded her back pay through Dec. 20, 2025.

He rejected the DOJ's argument that Article II of the Constitution gives the attorney general broad authority to remove an assistant U.S. attorney.

Accepting that argument, Furman wrote, would "unsettle the very equilibrium established by this nation's constitutional system."

That phrase sounds impressive.

It is also exactly backwards.

The Supreme Court Already Ruled the Opposite Way

Four months before Furman's ruling, the Supreme Court decided Trump v. Slaughter.

The justices overturned Humphrey's Executor, a 90-year-old precedent that let Congress wall off independent agency heads from presidential control.

The Daily Signal's verdict on the ruling: "the Constitution allows the president to be president."

Landmark Legal called it "a resounding victory for the separation of powers."

The Supreme Court said the opposite of what Furman just said.

A president who cannot fire the people enforcing his own laws is not actually running the executive branch.

That is not a radical idea.

It is Article II.

Furman walled off Maurene Comey's job using the Civil Service Reform Act instead of the removal protections the Supreme Court just killed.

Same theory, different label.

Congress does not get a veto over who works in Trump's Justice Department, whether that person runs the FTC or prosecutes cases in Manhattan.

Comey's Daughter Gets Protection Her Father Never Showed Conservatives

During that decade, she helped prosecute Ghislaine Maxwell and Sean "Diddy" Combs.

Nobody disputes she did real work on those cases.

That is not the point.

James Comey ran the FBI like his own fiefdom, leaked memos to trigger a special counsel against Trump, and later posted a beach photo spelling out "86 47" – a post critics say was a coded reference to killing the 47th president.

That post is why he is under federal indictment right now.

His daughter worked inside the same Justice Department culture that shielded him for years.

Furman just told Trump he cannot clean house.

DOJ's own spokesperson admitted to Fox News Digital that the department disagreed with the ruling, promising only to fight it "in due course."

Furman's Workaround Will Not Survive On Appeal

An Obama judge is trying to freeze Trump's Justice Department in amber, and the Supreme Court already told him no.

Trump v. Slaughter was not some narrow technical case.

It was the Supreme Court telling lower courts that presidents get to run their own executive branch, full stop.

Furman read that ruling, found a workaround, and used it to protect a Comey.

That is not a coincidence, and conservatives should not pretend it is.

Watch what happens on appeal.

The Second Circuit and eventually the Supreme Court will have to decide whether a 2026 precedent protecting presidential removal power stops at agency heads or reaches the thousands of DOJ lawyers carrying out the attorney general's orders.

Smart money says Trump wins that fight too, because the logic of Slaughter does not stop at the FTC's front door.

Until then, you are paying the salary of someone the president already fired once.

That is not justice.

That is one Obama judge buying the Comey family more time.

Sources:

  • Charles Creitz, "Obama Judge Rules Trump DOJ Illegally Fired James Comey's Daughter, Rejects Sweeping Article II Claim," Fox News, October 26, 2026.
  • Daily Signal Staff, "Trump v. Slaughter: Supreme Court Says Constitution Allows the President to Be President," The Daily Signal, June 29, 2026.
  • Landmark Legal Foundation, "Supreme Court Delivers Resounding Victory for Separation of Powers in Trump v. Slaughter, Overturning Humphrey's Executor," Landmark Legal, June 29, 2026.
  • Breitbart News, "Judge Rules That Maurene Comey Lawsuit Can Move Forward," Breitbart, April 2026.

Latest Posts: